Reflect a bit. A blog for people in Social Theory through Everyday Life, ANT 323, at the University of Toronto
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Clones, ink, social networking
Anyway, The Social Network was definitely not something I had expected. In a good way. Watching it, the thing that hit me most was how the camera and the narrative was everywhere, it was literally a mash-up of time. Although the three timelines were in chronological progression (events of 2003-4, lawsuit with the Winklevoss twins, lawsuit with Eduardo), they were meshed together in a way that was reminiscent of what Mitchell had called a 'new sense of time' in the age of biocybernetic reproduction. The biocybernetic part comes to play with the nature of Facebook replacing face-to-face interaction (as discussed in class today) in a world of information technology.
The film is also related to biocybernetics to an extent, I thought, because the film is about a 'real person' and 'real events'. It is literally a recreation (and re-interpretation) of humans through digital means - somewhat like clones, but intentionally made to be a little different from the original (the film is 'fiction'). This would justify the 'new sense of time' in the movie, which jumps back and forth and all over the place.
On a side note, there was an interesting quote I managed to get down - "The internet is printed in ink" as said by Erica in accusing Mark about insulting her on his blog. The internet, the digital medium, *printed*, in ink? It could be referring to the increasingly internet-dependent nature of today's literacy, as it emphasizes how things published on the internet holds a lot more influence than it might have in the past. But considering the volatile nature of the material online (susceptible to updates and changes, and is more flexible), compared to the fixed nature of the printed ink on paper, it might also point out how the internet and its lack of stability (it has no physical form) is meshed with the material reality in an ironic way. This could be a comment on Facebook (digital) replacing, or interlocking with, the real-life relationships (material, physical).
Monday, October 25, 2010
Counting Replicas
In retrospect, I realize that, in fact, I'm exposed to these replicas of the Mona Lisa's image daily but only realized this once I decided to pay attention.
I would suggest that all of you partake in this experiment and enlighten us with your own results.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Reproducing Art: Van Gogh 2.0
Earlier this month I found myself channel surfing and stumbled upon an infomercial. This isn’t an unusual occurrence, however, the content of the infomercial was laden with psychosocial undertones about art in a state of perpetual modernity and post modernity. The infomercial was selling an art kit; not just any art kit, but one that allowed the customer to reproduce the work of Picasso. “Painting by Numbers” is a simple concept – each painting was divided into colour slots, with each slot having a number that corresponded with a colour on the palette. The amateur artist then proceeds to paint by numbers, that is, fill in the colour that corresponds with the correct number on the palette. When all the numbers have been filled in, you have a perfect replica of one of Picasso’s famous works.
Upon seeing this, I was impressed, then immediately horrified. The act of admiring Picasso’s work is part technical, but part mystical as well; he was an innovator, an iconoclaste. To have his once seminal work reduced to a series of numbers akin to a logarithm, was (in my opinion) an insult to his contribution to the world of art, and devoid of any originality or creativity. This points to an interesting trend first identified by Walter Benjamin. Benjamin identified a trend in modern art with respect to reproduction – once a piece of art is reproduced it loses its essence, its originality and ultimately, it’s purpose. Now, as we enjoy the fruits of technology, art is being reproduced, reconfigured and ultimately degraded. Hindsight allows us to see how prophetic Walter Benjamin’s words were, and forces us to think critically about art an age of convenience.
"Dignified Death" as Oxymoron and Cartesian Mind/Body Dualism as Antidote
1.) the state or quality of being worthy of honour or respect
2.) a composed or serious manner of style
3.) a sense of pride in oneself
After leaving today's lecture, the notion of "dignified death" or "dying with dignity" struck me immediately. This of course extends beyond the tradition of burial, to our general conception of death and dead bodies as tranquil and peaceful. When coping with the death of a loved one, for instance, terms connoting peace are more favourable than those connoting violence. Suicide, often considered arguably (one of) the most violent and most tragic of deaths, is completely omitted in obituaries; people choose to ignore it. If the death is particularly brutal, like cancer for instance, the person is depicted as having attempted to "fight" the disease to the best of their abilities, thus the person maintains a sense of military pride in their last heroic actions.
The fact is there is no intrinsic dignity in death - dignity is an artificial, illusory creation that is imposed on the devastating instance of a person's death in order for the living to cope with the
This brings me to my next point, which is, that one of the most prevalent methods of coping with the notion of the body as fragile, vulnerable and mortal is the elevation of the importance of the mind over body, or interpretations of Cartesian Mind/Body dualism. Humans like to believe that the creative and spiritual capacity of the mind is evidence for a spiritually higher, less vulgar existence, either in this world or the next (e.g. heaven). However, ignoring our physical attributes leads us to only a partial understanding of ourselves, because our very raw physicality contributes so much to our existential condition - our physical interactions with the world, not just our rationalization of our interactions with the world, are just as significant as the latter (Young and Whitty 214). This is I think why images such as the one in this post of two skeletons from Pompeii seen in a kind of embrace gives us a sense of relief, because it suggests that "love" (considered a higher, spiritual experience and notion) continues on into death, even when our physical bodies have decayed. This very powerful image is a kind of triumph over death, or more accurately, triumph of mind over body.
*Random Tangent alert! - what follows is unorthodox cinematic treatments of death*
In keeping with our recent practice of examining the cinematic treatment of various theories explored in this course, I would like to bring up what I think is a very good example of how death is treated in a very "sacrilegious", unorthodox way through film. I am a big fan of Italian Cinema and have often observed in many instances that one of the reasons why many people find Italian films so jarring and vulgar, is due its common practice of juxtaposing the tragic with the comic in a very overt, unapologetic fashion. For instance, in "Roma, città aperta" immediately after a very disturbing scene in which a woman is tragically gunned down, the film continues to a very silly, slapstick scene in a which an old man is hit on the head with a frying pan. I saw this film in a class setting at UofT and many people thought that this was either just lazy film making due to the fact that there was no continuity between the two scenes in terms of mood or that it was just plain insensitive in ignoring the tragic death of the woman.
Examples of what a "respectable" cinematic treatment of death would be for scenes following the death depicted in the film to be coloured in some way by the tragic nature of the death. For example, the actions of the characters following the tragic scene would be without humour, or the mood of the scene would be slightly more sombre or serious, etc. Although this particular method of depicting death in cinema is perhaps more artistic in that there is a sense of continuity, it is not accurate. One of the most tragic aspects of dealing with the death of a loved one is the realization that life simply "goes on", as if the deceased individual had never existed. Traditionally, cinema thus functions as language to make sense or to make "proper" the problematic nature of death and dying; to prevent a full realization of the Real, whereas Italian Cinema often lets us view both the tragic and vulgar nature of death in its messy, unpredictable nature.
Sources:
Whitty, Monica T. and Garry Young. "In Search of the Cartesian Self: An Examination of Disembodiment within 21st-Communication." Theory & Psychology. 2010.
Roma, città aperta. 1945. Roberto Rossellini, dir.
Drive without Desire in Early Modern England
Thus, Talus possesses an an endless drive for justice - one that is separated from any specific object. Throughout the poem's fifth book, he attempts to kill anyone who commits (or assists in) any crime or social grievance, and must often be stopped by his master, Artegall, who acts as an agent of mercy. Insofar as he wishes to enact justice, Talus is different from cyborgs or zombies, as he does not simply wish to kill everyone. However, I feel both possess a similar endless drive that is threatening because detached from humane reality.
Sunday, October 17, 2010
The Mona Lisa
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uk2sPl_Z7ZU
Essentially it is a replica of the Mona Lisa created in MS Paint. I'm pretty sure that almost everyone in class has messed around with MS Paint and has access to it at home. Assuming you are as good as this artist in MS Paint you could technically just sit at your computer and make your own Mona Lisa replica. I just found it interesting how technology was being used here not for mass reproductions, but for the individual creation of the piece.
Sunday, October 10, 2010
My Trip to Queen St. East and Bertmount Ave.

Recently, I saw a photo of an interesting house downtown. And so I decided that I would go and take a look at it. I was hoping that my visit would help me answer the questions that were raised in the last tutorial. Why, for some reason, we often feel compelled to see the ‘original’.
Coincidentally, I had a friend who was paying me a short visit and since I knew he was a fan of new things, I asked him to visit the house with me. He hadn’t seen any photos of this house (in fact, I only told him that it was a house and nothing more), so I thought he could offer a totally unbiased opinion. After giving him probably what was deemed as an insufficient explanation as to why he had to drive all the way over to the East end of the city so I could see this house, struggling to locate in on his GPS, and taking twice the amount of time to get there (since his GPS indicated the trip would only take about 12 minutes without traffic) we arrived at Queen St. East and Bertmount safely.
The feeling of anticipation nestled in my stomach as I walked down Bertmount Ave, with my friend close behind. I told him, that he’d know what it was, when he saw it. You couldn’t miss it!
And so the house appeared before our eyes, with its army of dolls staring us down. My first thoughts of the ‘doll garden’ were that it was indeed a great collection, and the neighboring houses looked so plain next to it. But I had expected something that resembled more of an overwhelming mass of dolls… such that the house would be unrecognizable behind the crowd. And among the dolls, there were repeats, which seemed to take away from the garden’s uniqueness. This is not to say that I was disappointed. On the contrary, I enjoyed examining the garden closely and picking out dolls that I recognized. It was like being a little kid at somebody’s garage sale, and finding out that they also had some of the same toys.
On the other hand, my friend found it much less amusing. Their opinion of it was that it simply reminded them of Halloween and it seemed to provoke no more emotion than a yawn. Then again, I should keep in mind that this friend of mine is a minimalist in terms of emotional displays. In contrast, I am a more dramatic and emotional person. So his apathy was only to be expected, as I walked back and forth excitedly in front of the house, looking up and down their garden, expressing “ooooos” and “awws” as my eyes pored over the doll collection.
Did my viewing of the ‘doll garden’ in real life give me the feeling of “awe” as one would expect when they visit the Louvre to view the original Mona Lisa? Although I was very much intrigued by the display, my feeling of “awe” was smaller than I had anticipated. Indeed, the visual reality of the numerous dolls was there but there was no greater revelation than that.
However, I think the diminished or lack of an overwhelming feeling of “awe” is not necessarily due to the house, or in a more general sense, the Original’s uniqueness and “aura”. I think we have to consider ourselves as a factor, as ‘readers’ of the ‘text’. This relates back to what was discussed in class about Taste. If a doll enthusiast had seen both the photos of the ‘doll garden’ and in real life, I’m sure they would describe seeing the real doll garden as an eye-opening experience. Now, even though I’m not a doll lover, I still exuded more enthusiasm when I saw the garden. This was probably because I had built up a feeling of anticipation and had successfully persuading my friend to come with me. For my friend’s case, I take it that guys don’t like dolls so that would’ve accounted for the lack of interest.
So all in all, I think that the “aura” and feeling of “awe” that one yearns for when we search for 'originals’ will only be captured if there is an underlying basis for it. There needs to be a pre-existing relationship that the viewer and the ‘original’ have, such as an anticipation or a certain taste for it. I know that we may want to believe that it’s the Original’s innate “aura” and uniqueness that ignites the feeling of “awe” in us, but I think it’s like reading a different language. Something could be written very beautifully, but if we don’t understand the language, there will be no emotional experience.
(... I just realized that I haven't answered the question that I had asked myself at the beginning of this post... WHY we feel compelled to see Originals... >_<)